Table 7-Trials involving intralesional and intramuscular interferon treatment of genital warts
|
Study |
Treatment/trial type |
Patient number |
Immediate response during treatment |
Recurrence or study conclusion data |
|
Eron32 |
Interferon (1 X 106 international units
(IU)) directly into one to three warts three times weekly for three weeks
versus placebo |
257 patients |
At one week after the completion of therapy,
interferon had produced a large and significantly greater reduction in mean
wart area (a 62.4 percent decrease), as compared with placebo (a 1.2 percent
increase in mean area) (P less than 0.001). |
At the conclusion of the study (13 weeks after the
completion of therapy), the mean wart area was still decreased 39.9 percent
below the initial size in the interferon group, whereas it had increased by
46 percent over base-line measurements in the placebo group (P less than
0.001). At the same time, all treated warts had completely cleared in 36
percent of the interferon recipients and in 17 percent of the placebo
recipients (P less than 0.001), whereas treated warts progressed in 13
percent of the interferon recipients and in 50 percent of the placebo
recipients (P less than 0.001) |
|
Reichman47 |
1 x 106 units of interferon or placebo
injected three times per week for 4 weeks with either. |
79 |
Forty-seven percent of warts injected with
interferon resolved completely, compared with 22% of placebo-injected warts
(P = 0.009). |
Approximately one third of interferon-injected warts
recurred, compared with none of four placebo-injected warts. |
|
Panicin.46 |
51 were treated intramuscularly (IM) with 3 x 106
U (3 MU)/m2 daily for 3 weeks (total dose 63 MU/m2), 50
received subcutaneous thrice-weekly injections of 3 MU/m2 for 4
weeks (total dose 36 MU/m2), 51 underwent diathermocoagulation,
and 48 were not treated and were used as a control group |
200 |
. Six months after the end of treatment, the overall
response rate (complete and partial responses) was 70%: 57 and 82% for
patients receiving interferon alpha-2b (IM and subcutaneously) and
diathermocoagulation, respectively, and 8% for the control group. After 6
months from therapy, no significant differences in complete response were
found among the different types of treatment: 20, 20, and 35% for the two
interferon groups and the diathermocoagulation group, respectively. |
Fifteen and two complete responders in the
cauterization and interferon groups, respectively, experienced disease
recurrence (P less than .01). |
|
patients were randomized to receive either one
million international units (IU) of r-hIFN-β-1a or placebo
intralesionally into each lesion, 3 times a week, for a total of 9 occasions. |
60 patients with up to 8 distinct genital
warts. |
The complete response rate was not significantly
better with r-hIFN-beta-1a than with placebo. |
However, after 3 months, 73.3% of patients treated
with r-hIFN-beta-1a had experienced at least a partial response to treatment,
compared with 33.3% of placebo-treated patients. At 19 days and 6 weeks,
r-hIFN-beta-1a produced a significantly larger reduction in the area of
genital warts. Lesions with detectable HPV6 or 11 showed a trend towards a
better response rate to treatment with r-hIFN-beta-1a than lesions where no
HPV DNA was detected. |